Underground Easements and Potential Impacts on Property Value
Author(s): Jaikaran Goraya
November 20, 2026

If a subway tunnel or other permanent infrastructure is to be built under your property, an obvious question is: will it affect what your property is worth?
As Ontario continues to invest in major public transit infrastructure, property owners may increasingly find themselves dealing with an unfamiliar form of expropriation: the acquisition of property rights beneath their land. Projects such as the Ontario Line, Yonge North Subway Extension and Eglinton Crosstown West Extension involve substantial underground infrastructure, potentially requiring permanent subsurface interests beneath privately owned properties. This raises an important question: even if the infrastructure is well below the surface, could its presence affect your property’s market value?
There is currently very little judicial guidance on this point. In the 1968 decision Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College v. Municipality of Metropolitan Toronto, the Supreme Court of Canada considered compensation arising from a permanent subsurface easement expropriated for subway purposes. The case illustrates the distinction between the value of the interest acquired and any diminution in the value of the remaining property. Specifically, underground infrastructure can impair the economic attributes of the surface estate through construction restrictions, foundation requirements, or other limitations on redevelopment.
A more recent example is Lin v. Metrolinx, a case before the Local Planning Appeal Tribunal which concerned a permanent subsurface easement for tiebacks required to facilitate infrastructure improvements along a GO transit corridor in Toronto. One of the appraisers in this case took the position that the nature of the easement did not necessarily mitigate its effect because it remained a permanent easement and described the easement as a “cloud on title” with a “dampening effect on market value.”
That evidence identifies an important practical question for property owners: even if underground infrastructure does not presently interfere with the use of a property, could its permanent presence influence a future purchaser?
The answer depends on the evidence. In Lin, the Tribunal considered not only the permanent nature of the easement, but also its depth and non-intrusive character, existing restrictions affecting the property, and market evidence relating to its effect on the remainder by way of a paired sales analysis comparing property sales of properties also subject to the same easement expropriated for the same purposes. In other words, the Tribunal took a highly contextual approach.
For a property owner, potential concerns might include whether an easement expropriated underground affects future redevelopment or construction. Other perceived concerns associated with major underground infrastructure may also arise, including, but not limited to, construction impacts on existing buildings or nuisance issues such as vibration or noise.
Timing may complicate the issue further. Concerns associated primarily with construction may diminish once work is complete, while others associated with a permanent easement may continue. An assessment of compensation therefore requires careful attention to the nature of the alleged impact of the expropriation on the property and the available evidence.
The important takeaway for property owners is that a permanent underground easement does not automatically establish a loss in property value, but its impact should not automatically be dismissed simply because it is underground. The question is whether the evidence demonstrates that there is an impact to the market value of the remaining property from the subsurface easement.
If you or someone you know is affected by these underground projects, find out about your legal rights regarding expropriation and see answers to Expropriation FAQs. Contact Thomson Rogers expropriation lawyers to learn your rights.
Share this