Article, Expropriation

Mississauga Moves to Expropriate Port Credit Properties: What the Yonge-Dundas Precedent Tells Us

Author(s): Ben Horovatin, Denitza Koev

November 18, 2026


After hundreds of police calls and more than 50 arrests associated with two Port Credit properties between January 2025 and August 2026, the City of Mississauga has decided to expropriate 34 and 36 Peter Street North, demolish the buildings and use the lands for public parking.1

Expropriation is more commonly associated with highways, transit projects and other major public works. Mississauga’s proposal raises a broader question: how far can a municipality’s expropriation powers extend when it seeks to address public-safety, social and economic concerns as part of a wider plan for an area? 

The landmark Yonge-Dundas proceeding shows how section 28 of Ontario’s Planning Act can provide a framework for municipal land acquisition and expropriation where the concerns extend beyond deteriorated buildings.2

The statutory framework

Section 28 allows a municipality with enabling official plan policies to designate a community improvement project area and adopt a Community Improvement Plan (“CIP”) for that area. Once the required by-law has been passed, subsection 28(3) expressly permits the municipality to acquire and hold land within the project area and to clear, grade, or otherwise prepare it for community improvement.

The Planning Act authorizes acquisition for that planning purpose. If the land cannot be acquired by agreement, the Expropriations Act supplies the compulsory acquisition processes, including approval, any available hearing of necessity, and compensation.3

A CIP does not, by itself, make every proposed taking appropriate. The acquisition must advance the municipality’s authorized community improvement purpose, and the statutory expropriation process must still be followed.

How Yonge-Dundas tested the scope of that power 

In the 1990s, the Yonge-Dundas area faced declining commercial vitality and significant public-safety and social concerns. Toronto adopted a CIP that contemplated a new public square above an underground parking garage, together with coordinated entertainment and retail development. Implementing the plan required the acquisition of ten privately owned properties, including by expropriation if necessary. 

Several owners challenged the proposal, including a landowner represented by our retired partner, Roger Beaman and current partner, Jeff Wilker. The material question was whether the lands could properly be designated for community improvement, and consequently acquired or expropriated to carry out the plan, when the City’s concerns were not confined to physical deterioration or traditional urban blight. 

In the resulting tribunal proceedings4, Marvin Hertzman Holdings Inc. v. Toronto (City),the Ontario Joint Board accepted a broader interpretation. It concluded that community improvement could respond to the area’s social and economic conditions and found that the individual properties could not achieve the comprehensive change sought by the City. The Divisional Court upheld the decision5 and the recommendation that the expropriation plans be approved.

The statutory wording has since become more explicit. At the time of the Yonge-Dundas proceeding, the definition of a community improvement project area referred to specific physical conditions and concluded with the broad phrase “or for any other reason”. The current definition expressly refers to environmental, social and community economic development reasons. This wording was adopted by the Legislature6 directly in response to Yonge-Dundas7, to make clear that a CIP can address such reasons.

From Yonge-Dundas to Port Credit

The Mississauga properties fall within the Port Credit Growth Node, one of five strategic growth areas covered by the City’s 2026 Hurontario Growth Area Community Improvement Plan8 (“HGACIP”). The HGACIP is principally an office-development incentive program, but identifies broader objectives for Port Credit, including improving the public realm, balancing growth and existing character, and promoting a healthy and complete community.

Mississauga has not publicly identified the HGACIP or section 28 as the legal basis for these proposed takings. The comparison therefore should not be overstated. Still, Yonge-Dundas illustrates the potential reach of municipal expropriation powers when land acquisition forms part of a comprehensive and authorized community improvement strategy addressing social, economic and public-realm concerns.

Whether Mississauga’s proposed takings are fair, sound and reasonably necessary will depend on the City’s stated objectives, the evidentiary record and the statutory process. Yonge-Dundas does not decide that issue. It does however show that municipal expropriation is not necessarily confined to conventual infrastructure or the removal of physical blight.

Terms defined 

Community Improvement Plan (CIP): A municipal planning tool under section 28 of the Planning Act for the improvement of a designated community improvement project area. 

Community improvement project area: An area designated by municipal by-law because council considers improvement desirable for reasons identifies in the Planning Act, including environmental, social or community economic development reasons. 

Expropriation: The compulsory acquisition of private property by a public authority, subject to Ontario’s statutory process and compensation requirements. 

Hearing of necessity: A process in which an inquiry officer considers whether a proposed taking is fair, sound and reasonably necessary to achieve the approving authority’s objectives. 

Hurontario Growth Area Community Improvement Plan (HGACIP): Mississauga’s 2026 plan for five strategic growth areas along the Hazel McCallion Line, including the Port Credit Growth Node.


Thomson Rogers LLP’s Municipal & Expropriation Law Group advises property owners and public bodies on expropriation, land use planning and Ontario Land Tribunal proceedings. Schedule a free consultation with the Expropriation Law team at Thomson Rogers LLP. Call 416-868-3100 or 1-888-223-0448, or contact us online.


  1. See “Police attended 2 Mississauga homes hundreds of times in 18 months. Now the city wants to expropriate them” by Codi Wilson, CP24, November 3, 2026. ↩︎
  2. See Marvin Hertzman Holdings Inc. v. Toronto (City), (1998), 36 OMBR 321, 1998 CarswellOnt 2293 (Ont. Joint Bd.); affirmed (1998), 48 MPLR (2d) 65 (Ont. Div. Ct.); additional reasons at (February 2, 1999), Doc. Toronto 427/98 (Ont. Div. Ct.); refused leave to appeal (1998), 165 DLR (4th) 529n (Ont. C.A.). [“Yonge-Dudas Decision”] ↩︎
  3. See our page on “Public Authority Expropriation”.  ↩︎
  4. See page 40 of the Joint Board decision. ↩︎
  5. See para 43 of the Divisional Court decision. ↩︎
  6. See section 7 of the amending Brownfields Statute Law Amendment Act, 2001, S.O. 2001, c. 17 – Bill 56 which amended the Planning Act. ↩︎
  7. During the Standing Committee on General Government held on Monday 15, October 2001, Mr. Faieta directly referenced the recent City of Toronto decision to explain the proposed amended wording for section 28. The amendments were then carried. See the related Hansard transcripts. ↩︎
  8. See the Hurontario Growth Area Community Improvement Plan. ↩︎

Share this


Related articles:

Stay Informed

Subscribe to receive updates on the latest news from Thomson Rogers LLP as well as invitations to seminars, webinars and more.

Sign up now